Why one flood insurance quote isn't enough: the same home quoted across every carrier

Name: Yep Insurance flood quote comparison, October 2026
Creator: Yep Insurance

No. Across 10 real homes, 6 different carriers were cheapest¹, and quotes for the same home differed by up to 48.8×.

¹ Hiscox quoted through different platforms counts once. The NFIP counts as a carrier. P04, P05, P06 and P08 are all Hiscox.

Written by Glenn Willis, licensed flood insurance professional at Yep Insurance. [License #: TBD - States: TBD]

Published October 21, 2026 · Last updated October 21, 2026

The short answer: we quoted 10 real, publicly listed homes across every carrier available to us on four platforms: 122 quotes at a $5,000 deductible (one of them preliminary) plus 7 NFIP indications that cannot be bound. 6 different carriers came out cheapest. Prices for the same home varied by 2.9× to 48.8×, and the NFIP was cheapest just 1 time. No single carrier, and no price range, could have predicted the winner for any of these homes.

Quoted Oct 20–21, 2026 · Building $250,000 / contents $0 / $5,000 deductible · Every figure comes from Yep's own quote records

Key findings

6different carriers were cheapest across 10 homes

4.9×median gap between a home's highest and lowest quote (range 2.9× to 48.8×)

1 of 10homes where the NFIP was the cheapest option

4 of 4quoting platforms produced at least one winning quote

Every property is a brand-new case. Neptune was cheapest on two homes and the most expensive option on another.
The zone didn't set the price. On two Zone X homes the lowest quotes were $125 and $435, while one of them drew NFIP quotes of $4,600 or more.
Appetite changes everything. Condo units, barrier islands, elevation, ZIP code and state each knocked out carriers, so some homes had 20 quotes and one had only 4.
Ten more homes would give you a whole new leaderboard. With 6 different winners in 10 homes, the pattern is clear: there is no "usual" cheapest carrier. You only find the winner by quoting every carrier, every time.

Quotes use assumed foundation and building details where noted on each card. Verified details will change prices.

Cheapest carrier by property

Lowest annual premium at a $5,000 deductible. All-in prices with fees and tax appear on each card where the platform showed them.

Home	Location	FEMA zone	Cheapest carrier	Lowest premium	Lowest NFIP	High ÷ low
P01	Cape Coral, FL 33904	AE	Bankers NFIPRocket MGA	$3,397	$3,397	3.4×
P02	St Pete Beach, FL 33706	AE	NeptuneRocket MGA	$2,129	$4,638	7.9×
P03	Galveston, TX 77554	AE	Sterling FloodSterling	$1,511.47	$2,550	6.4×
P04	Naples, FL 34120	AH	Co3 HiscoxCRC (Argenia)	$386	$1,673	4.3×
P05	Ocean City, NJ 08226	AE	HiscoxFlow	$669.78	$2,878	4.3×
P06	Folly Beach, SC 29439	VE	HiscoxFlow	$2,779.77	$5,604	5.3×
P07	Huntington Beach, CA 92648	AE	Millennial SuttonRocket MGA	$410	$1,838	4.5×
P08	Charlotte, NC 28205	X	HiscoxFlow	$125	$529	8.0×
P09	Newport, KY 41071	X	NeptuneRocket MGA	$746	$2,200	2.9×
P10	Jamestown, CO 80455	X	Co4 CGM-DPFIPCRC (Argenia)	$435	$4,600	48.8×

"Lowest NFIP" is the lowest NFIP quote at a $5,000 deductible on the platform. For P02 and P03 the platform rated the home Zone VE although FEMA's map shows AE, so those NFIP figures are probably overstated (see the cards).

The case studies

Each card lists every quote we received for that home from lowest to highest, along with the declines, the assumptions we had to make, and what moved the price. Street addresses are left out on purpose. FocusFlood (effective-date window not met on several) and DUAL (no quotes) returned nothing usable on any property.

P01

Cape Coral, FL 33904

Single-family, 1 story, built 1974 (concrete block)

Cheapest$3,397Bankers NFIP · Rocket MGA

FEMA zone: AE
BFE: 8 ft
Ground vs BFE: −2.54 ft
Spread: 3.4× (11 quotes at $5k ded.)
vs NFIP: NFIP was cheapest
Quoted: Oct 20–21, 2026

All quotes, lowest to highest (annual premium)

Bankers NFIPRocket MGA · wait: 30 days$3,397
NAT GEN NFIPRocket MGA · wait: 30 days$3,397
Wright NFIPRocket MGA · wait: 30 days$3,397
NFIP (RR2.0 indication, $2k ded)Flow · indication only, $2,000 deductible; not bindable$3,509
HiscoxFlow$8,473.93
AON EdgeRocket MGA$8,827
Co3 Hiscox 17919CRC (Argenia) · all-in $10,189.44, wait: 7 days (waivable)$9,607
AnnexRocket MGA$9,665
Sterling FloodSterling$9,856.35
Wright HiscoxRocket MGA$10,137
Co8 VaveCRC (Argenia) · all-in $11,981.27, wait: 7 days (waivable)$11,114
VaveFlow$11,446.48

Private NFIP · Building $250,000 / contents $0 / $5,000 deductible unless noted · FIRM panel 12071C0403G, effective 2022-11-17

Declines & exclusions

CAT Coverage and Beyond Floods: not available in Florida

Assumptions

Slab foundation ASSUMED (not confirmed). No elevation certificate; first-floor height not measured.

What moved the price

The NFIP won here, and it wasn't close. All three NFIP companies on the platform quoted the same $3,397. The cheapest private quote (Hiscox through Flow, $8,473.93) was about 2.5× that. Every private carrier we quoted came in above $8,400.

The ground is rated 2.54 ft below the base flood elevation, and that matters a lot here. On this risk, the private carriers' own models priced it far above the NFIP. Sterling's deductible options barely moved the price: $10,156.65 at a $1,000 deductible vs $9,556.05 at $10,000.

P02

St Pete Beach, FL 33706

Condo unit, 4th floor, built 1973 (block/stucco)

Cheapest$2,129Neptune · Rocket MGA

FEMA zone: AE (one platform rated it VE)
BFE: 11 ft
Ground vs BFE: −4.78 ft (ground; unit is on the 4th floor)
Spread: 7.9× (8 quotes at $5k ded.)
vs NFIP: $2,509 below the lowest NFIP quote
Quoted: Oct 20–21, 2026

All quotes, lowest to highest (annual premium)

NeptuneRocket MGA$2,129
Co8 VaveCRC (Argenia) · all-in $4,739.39, wait: 7 days (waivable)$4,265
Wright NFIPRocket MGA · wait: 30 days$4,638
Bankers NFIPRocket MGA · wait: 30 days$5,595
NAT GEN NFIPRocket MGA · wait: 30 days$5,595
NFIP (RR2.0 indication, $2k ded)Flow · indication only, $2,000 deductible; not bindable$6,314
Co12 GLK FLRPCRC (Argenia) · all-in $8,001.87$7,323
Co3 HiscoxCRC (Argenia) · all-in $10,414.08, wait: 7 days (waivable)$9,821
Sterling FloodSterling$16,789.50

Private NFIP · Building $250,000 / contents $0 / $5,000 deductible unless noted · FIRM panel 12103C0276H, effective 2021-08-24

Declines & exclusions

Beyond Floods, Millennial, Hiscox, AON Edge (Rocket MGA): condo unit ineligible
All private carriers on Flow: not eligible (NFIP indication only)
CAT Coverage and Beyond Floods: not available in Florida
Other CRC Company N carriers: no quote returned

Assumptions

Secondary home, masonry, slab ASSUMED (Rocket MGA). On CRC there is no condo-unit form, so it was entered as a 4-story masonry building elevated 20 ft (ASSUMED).

What moved the price

Condo units shrink the field fast. Beyond Floods, Millennial, Hiscox and AON Edge declined the unit on one platform, and on another every private carrier was ineligible. Neptune came in lowest at $2,129. The next private option was Vave through CRC at $4,265 ($4,739.39 with fees and tax).

A caution on the NFIP number: FEMA's map shows Zone AE at this building, but the quoting platform rated it Zone VE, so its NFIP prices are probably too high. The three NFIP companies also didn't agree here. Wright quoted $4,638, while Bankers and NAT GEN quoted $5,595 for the same coverage. We haven't confirmed why.

P03

Galveston, TX 77554

Single-family, elevated coastal, built 2004

Cheapest$1,511.47Sterling Flood · Sterling

FEMA zone: AE (VE within 200 m; one platform rated it VE)
BFE: 15 ft (platform used VE BFE 16 ft)
Ground vs BFE: −2.19 ft (as rated against BFE 16)
Spread: 6.4× (12 quotes at $5k ded.)
vs NFIP: $1,038.53 below the lowest NFIP quote
Quoted: Oct 20–21, 2026

All quotes, lowest to highest (annual premium)

Sterling FloodSterling$1,511.47
NeptuneRocket MGA$1,936
Beyond Floods EssentialRocket MGA$2,016
Beyond Floods EnhancedRocket MGA$2,340
Wright NFIPRocket MGA · wait: 30 days$2,550
Beyond Floods EliteRocket MGA$2,624
HiscoxFlow$2,683.15
Wright HiscoxRocket MGA$2,957
NAT GEN NFIPRocket MGA · wait: 30 days$3,016
Bankers NFIPRocket MGA · wait: 30 days$3,016
AON EdgeRocket MGA$8,918
Co3 HiscoxCRC (Argenia) · all-in $10,181.67, wait: 7 days (waivable)$9,607

Private NFIP · Building $250,000 / contents $0 / $5,000 deductible unless noted · FIRM panel 48167C0504G, effective 2019-08-15

Declines & exclusions

Annex: excluded by ZIP code
Other CRC Company N carriers: no quote returned

Assumptions

Flow quote: foundation updated to elevated over an enclosure for underwriting approval. Pilings with open enclosure ASSUMED (Rocket MGA; portal prefill said 1 story frame, records say 1.5 story). Pilings elevated 8 ft ASSUMED (CRC).

What moved the price

The winner was a carrier quoted directly, not the platform with the most carriers. Sterling Flood came in at $1,511.47, ahead of Neptune ($1,936) and Beyond Floods Essential ($2,016). At the top end, AON Edge ($8,918) and Hiscox through CRC ($9,607) were about 6× the winner.

FEMA maps the house in Zone AE, with Zone VE on the beach side less than 200 m away. One platform rated it VE, so its NFIP figures ($2,550 to $3,016) are probably overstated. Again the NFIP companies disagreed (Wright $2,550 vs $3,016), for reasons not yet confirmed. Annex excluded the ZIP code. Flow first referred the risk to underwriting; after the foundation was updated to elevated over an enclosure, Flow's underwriters approved it, and Hiscox through Flow quoted $2,683.15.

P04

Naples, FL 34120

Single-family, high-value, built 2015 (masonry/stucco)

Cheapest$386Co3 Hiscox · CRC (Argenia)

FEMA zone: AH
BFE: None published
Ground vs BFE: +1.65 ft (as rated)
Spread: 4.3× (15 quotes at $5k ded.)
vs NFIP: $1,287 below the lowest NFIP quote
Quoted: Oct 20–21, 2026

All quotes, lowest to highest (annual premium)

Co3 HiscoxCRC (Argenia) · all-in $510.16, wait: 7 days (waivable)$386
HiscoxFlow$414.35
Millennial SuttonRocket MGA$420
Co8 VaveCRC (Argenia) · all-in $685.41, wait: 7 days (waivable)$553
VaveFlow$574.57
Sterling FloodSterling$670.95
NFIP Equivalent+Flow$672
NeptuneRocket MGA$681
Co4 CGM-DPFIPCRC (Argenia) · all-in $939.48$795
BritFlow$969
Co5 CGM-DPFIPCRC (Argenia) · all-in $1,138.93$985
Annex (alert)Rocket MGA · preliminary$1,125
Bankers NFIPRocket MGA · wait: 30 days$1,673
NAT GEN NFIPRocket MGA · wait: 30 days$1,673
Wright NFIPRocket MGA · wait: 30 days$1,673
NFIP (RR2.0 indication, $1,250 ded)Flow · indication only, $1,250 deductible; not bindable$1,711

Private NFIP · Building $250,000 / contents $0 / $5,000 deductible unless noted · FIRM panel 12021C0217H, effective 2012-05-16

Declines & exclusions

CAT Coverage and Beyond Floods: not available in Florida

Assumptions

Slab foundation ASSUMED. Zone AH at the point should be confirmed on a FIRMette (the lot borders X/AE/AH).

What moved the price

The same carrier came in at different prices on different platforms. Hiscox was cheapest through CRC at $386 base premium, or $510.16 all-in once the $100 fee and $24.16 tax are added. Through Flow, Hiscox was $414.35, and Millennial Sutton was $420. Only CRC itemizes fees and tax, so on an all-in basis the order could change. That's why we compare the final price, not just the headline premium.

The NFIP was $1,673 (the same at all three companies). The Annex figure ($1,125) was flagged as preliminary until the application is re-created in Annex's own portal.

P05

Ocean City, NJ 08226

Single-family, built 1925 (barrier island)

Cheapest$669.78Hiscox · Flow

FEMA zone: AE
BFE: 9 ft
Ground vs BFE: −4.1 ft (as rated)
Spread: 4.3× (11 quotes at $5k ded.)
vs NFIP: $2,208.22 below the lowest NFIP quote
Quoted: Oct 20–21, 2026

All quotes, lowest to highest (annual premium)

HiscoxFlow$669.78
AON EdgeRocket MGA$817
CAT CoverageRocket MGA$821
Wright HiscoxRocket MGA$831
NeptuneRocket MGA$893
Co8 VaveCRC (Argenia) · all-in $1,019.15, wait: 7 days (waivable)$923
Sterling FloodSterling$1,005.20
VaveFlow$1,351.11
Bankers NFIPRocket MGA · wait: 30 days$2,878
NAT GEN NFIPRocket MGA · wait: 30 days$2,878
Wright NFIPRocket MGA · wait: 30 days$2,878
NFIP (RR2.0 indication, $2k ded)Flow · indication only, $2,000 deductible; not bindable$2,926

Private NFIP · Building $250,000 / contents $0 / $5,000 deductible unless noted · FIRM panel 34009C0089F, effective 2017-10-05

Declines & exclusions

Millennial Sutton: barrier island ineligible
Annex: excluded by elevation
Other CRC Company N carriers: no quote returned

Assumptions

Vented crawlspace and frame construction ASSUMED (Rocket MGA; listing suggests masonry and an elevated crawl). Built 1970 and 1,500 sq ft ASSUMED on CRC.

What moved the price

Private flood beat the NFIP by more than $2,200. Hiscox through Flow was $669.78. The NFIP was $2,878 at all three companies. Vave shows how much the platform matters: $923 through CRC vs $1,351.11 through Flow.

Appetite cut both ways. Millennial Sutton declined because the home is on a barrier island, and Annex declined based on elevation.

P06

Folly Beach, SC 29439

Single-family, elevated coastal, built 2001 (renovated 2022)

Cheapest$2,779.77Hiscox · Flow

FEMA zone: VE
BFE: 12 ft
Ground vs BFE: −2.33 ft (as rated)
Spread: 5.3× (10 quotes at $5k ded.)
vs NFIP: $2,824.23 below the lowest NFIP quote
Quoted: Oct 20–21, 2026

All quotes, lowest to highest (annual premium)

HiscoxFlow$2,779.77
Beyond Floods EssentialRocket MGA$5,188
Bankers NFIPRocket MGA · wait: 30 days$5,604
NAT GEN NFIPRocket MGA · wait: 30 days$5,604
Beyond Floods EnhancedRocket MGA$6,035
Beyond Floods EliteRocket MGA$6,779
Sterling FloodSterling$7,269.48
Co3 Hiscox 17920 Coastal VCRC (Argenia) · all-in $10,289.42, wait: 7 days (waivable)$9,607
Co8 VaveCRC (Argenia) · all-in $14,030.16, wait: 7 days (waivable)$12,936
NeptuneRocket MGA$14,710

Private NFIP · Building $250,000 / contents $0 / $5,000 deductible unless noted · FIRM panel 45019C0692K, effective 2021-01-29

Declines & exclusions

Annex: excluded by elevation
Other CRC Company N carriers: no quote returned

Assumptions

Flow quote: foundation updated to elevated over an enclosure for underwriting approval. Pilings with open enclosure, 2 story, 1,908 sq ft ASSUMED (Rocket MGA; records say 1,840). Pilings elevated 10 ft, built 2001 ASSUMED (CRC).

What moved the price

Underwriting changed the winner. Flow first referred this home to underwriting without a price. After the foundation was updated to elevated over an enclosure, Flow's underwriters approved it, and Hiscox through Flow came in at $2,779.77, the lowest quote for this home. The next-best quotes were Beyond Floods Essential at $5,188 and the NFIP at $5,604.

The same carrier that won P02 and P09, Neptune, was the most expensive here at $14,710. Annex declined on elevation.

P07

Huntington Beach, CA 92648

Single-family (details from portal prefill)

Cheapest$410Millennial Sutton · Rocket MGA

FEMA zone: AE
BFE: 5.3 ft
Ground vs BFE: −3.08 ft (as rated)
Spread: 4.5× (14 quotes at $5k ded.)
vs NFIP: $1,428 below the lowest NFIP quote
Quoted: Oct 20–21, 2026

All quotes, lowest to highest (annual premium)

Millennial SuttonRocket MGA$410
Sterling FloodSterling$463.52
HiscoxFlow$497.49
Co3 HiscoxCRC (Argenia) · all-in $659.24, wait: 7 days (waivable)$542
NFIP Equivalent+Flow$648.73
CAT CoverageRocket MGA$754
NeptuneRocket MGA$829
Beyond Floods EssentialRocket MGA$1,137
Beyond Floods EnhancedRocket MGA$1,316
Beyond Floods EliteRocket MGA$1,472
WestfieldFlow$1,521
Bankers NFIPRocket MGA · wait: 30 days$1,838
NAT GEN NFIPRocket MGA · wait: 30 days$1,838
Wright NFIPRocket MGA · wait: 30 days$1,838
NFIP (RR2.0 indication, $2k ded)Flow · indication only, $2,000 deductible; not bindable$1,867

Private NFIP · Building $250,000 / contents $0 / $5,000 deductible unless noted · FIRM panel 06059C0234J, effective 2009-12-03

Declines & exclusions

Annex: excluded by elevation
Other CRC Company N carriers: no quote returned

Assumptions

Slab foundation ASSUMED; 1980, 2 story, frame per portal prefill. Year built and foundation were not confirmed from public records.

What moved the price

The top three private quotes were close, and all far below the NFIP. Millennial Sutton was $410, Sterling Flood $463.52 and Hiscox (Flow) $497.49, compared with $1,838 from the NFIP. Annex declined on elevation.

When the top quotes are this close, coverage details and fees decide the winner, not just the premium.

P08

Charlotte, NC 28205

Single-family, 1 story, built 1953 (brick)

Cheapest$125Hiscox · Flow

FEMA zone: X
BFE: n/a
Ground vs BFE: n/a
Spread: 8.0× (19 quotes at $5k ded.)
vs NFIP: $404 below the lowest NFIP quote
Quoted: Oct 20–21, 2026

All quotes, lowest to highest (annual premium)

HiscoxFlow$125
VaveFlow$150
Sterling FloodSterling$151.63
Wright HiscoxRocket MGA$182
CAT CoverageRocket MGA$182
AON EdgeRocket MGA$197
Beyond Floods EssentialRocket MGA$211
Beyond Floods EnhancedRocket MGA$240
Beyond Floods EliteRocket MGA$267
AnnexRocket MGA$371
BritFlow$400
NeptuneRocket MGA$428
Co4 CGM-DPFIPCRC (Argenia) · all-in $639.14$512
Bankers NFIPRocket MGA · wait: 30 days$529
NAT GEN NFIPRocket MGA · wait: 30 days$529
Wright NFIPRocket MGA · wait: 30 days$529
NFIP (RR2.0 indication, $2k ded)Flow · indication only, $2,000 deductible; not bindable$540
NFIP Equivalent+Flow$585
Co7 CSL-DPFICRC (Argenia) · all-in $830.78$694
Co11 PF-D2CRC (Argenia) · all-in $1,153, wait: 30 days$1,000

Private NFIP · Building $250,000 / contents $0 / $5,000 deductible unless noted · FIRM panel 3710456500K, effective 2014-02-19

Declines & exclusions

None recorded for this home.

Assumptions

Vented crawlspace ASSUMED; main house only (detached studio excluded).

What moved the price

Even a low-risk Zone X home had an 8× spread. Hiscox through Flow was $125, while the highest quote (Co11 PF-D2 through CRC) was $1,000. The NFIP was $529. This property drew 20 quotes, the most of any home here, and only one of them was the lowest.

P09

Newport, KY 41071

Single-family, 2 story, built 1897 (tenant-occupied rental)

Cheapest$746Neptune · Rocket MGA

FEMA zone: X (levee-protected area adjacent)
BFE: n/a
Ground vs BFE: n/a
Spread: 2.9× (4 quotes at $5k ded.)
vs NFIP: $1,454 below the lowest NFIP quote
Quoted: Oct 20–21, 2026

All quotes, lowest to highest (annual premium)

NeptuneRocket MGA$746
Bankers NFIPRocket MGA · wait: 30 days$2,200
NAT GEN NFIPRocket MGA · wait: 30 days$2,200
Wright NFIPRocket MGA · wait: 30 days$2,200

Private NFIP · Building $250,000 / contents $0 / $5,000 deductible unless noted · FIRM panel 21037C0028F, effective 2021-08-10

Declines & exclusions

Most private carriers on Rocket MGA: Kentucky not available (only Neptune quoted)
Sterling Flood: no flood quote available for this risk
Flow: Kentucky not available
CRC: flood not available in Kentucky

Assumptions

Stone foundation entered as crawlspace (ASSUMED); landlord/rental occupancy.

What moved the price

Where you live decides who can quote at all. In Kentucky, CRC's flood program and Flow weren't available, Sterling had no quote for this risk, and most private carriers on Rocket MGA don't write the state. The only private quote was Neptune at $746. The NFIP was $2,200.

P10

Jamestown, CO 80455

Single-family, 2 story, built 1999 (frame, mountain creek town)

Cheapest$435Co4 CGM-DPFIP · CRC (Argenia)

FEMA zone: X (shaded 0.2% at the lot edge)
BFE: n/a (AE floodway about 40 m away)
Ground vs BFE: n/a
Spread: 48.8× (18 quotes at $5k ded.)
vs NFIP: $4,165 below the lowest NFIP quote
Quoted: Oct 20–21, 2026

All quotes, lowest to highest (annual premium)

Co4 CGM-DPFIPCRC (Argenia) · all-in $551.99$435
Sterling FloodSterling$442.90
NFIP Equivalent+Flow$519
WestfieldFlow$667
Co7 CSL-DPFICRC (Argenia) · all-in $794.45$670
Co11 PF-D2CRC (Argenia) · all-in $825.40, wait: 30 days$700
CAT CoverageRocket MGA$1,941
NeptuneRocket MGA$2,169
VaveFlow$3,192.54
HiscoxFlow$3,247.44
AON EdgeRocket MGA$3,905
NAT GEN NFIPRocket MGA · wait: 30 days$4,600
Millennial SuttonRocket MGA$5,398
Bankers NFIPRocket MGA · wait: 30 days$5,996
Wright NFIPRocket MGA · wait: 30 days$5,996
NFIP (RR2.0 indication, $2k ded)Flow · indication only, $2,000 deductible; not bindable$6,044
Beyond Floods EssentialRocket MGA$15,528
Beyond Floods EnhancedRocket MGA$18,608
Beyond Floods EliteRocket MGA$21,223

Private NFIP · Building $250,000 / contents $0 / $5,000 deductible unless noted · FIRM panel 08013C0357K, effective 2024-10-24

Declines & exclusions

None recorded for this home.

Assumptions

Slab foundation ASSUMED (no basement confirmed); frame, 2 story; tenant-occupied.

What moved the price

Zone X, and still a 48.8× spread. Co4 CGM-DPFIP through CRC was $435 ($551.99 all-in). Beyond Floods Elite was $21,223. The NFIP quoted $4,600 to $5,996 at a $5,000 deductible, and the three NFIP companies didn't match: NAT GEN was $4,600, while Bankers and Wright were $5,996. A later re-pull of the saved quote showed $5,782 at all three. A separate NFIP indication at a $2,000 deductible was $6,044.

A "low-risk" zone label told us almost nothing about this home's price. The nearby creek and floodway are a likely reason, but each carrier's model is its own.

Where private flood didn't win

Cape Coral, FL (P01): the NFIP's $3,397 beat every private quote. The lowest private quote was $8,473.93. If we had only quoted private carriers, this owner would have overpaid by more than $5,000 a year.

St Pete Beach, FL and Galveston, TX (P02, P03): one platform rated both homes Zone VE, but FEMA's map shows AE at each building. Their NFIP quotes are probably too high, so private flood's apparent advantage on those two homes may be smaller than it looks.

Being honest about these cases is the point. The goal isn't "always private" or "always NFIP." It's the cheapest suitable policy for this home.

Why a page of price ranges can't tell you your price

Some pages publish general flood insurance price ranges, like "most homeowners pay between X and Y." Ranges like that have three built-in problems:

They blend homes that have nothing in common. Across these 10 homes, the lowest quote ran from $125 to $3,397.
They hide the spread within a single home. For one Zone X house, the quotes ran from $435 to $21,223.
They can't say which carrier will win. 6 different carriers won 10 homes, so no range can tell you where you land or who to call.

A range can't be checked against a real property, and it can't price yours. Only real quotes for your home can.

How carriers really price flood risk

A FEMA zone is just one input. Private carriers layer their own risk models and data on top of it, and each one decides for itself which homes it will write. In our records, the inputs that changed prices or eligibility included:

Elevation relative to BFE. Annex declined three homes based on elevation.
Building type and occupancy. A 4th-floor condo unit was ineligible with many carriers, and a tenant-occupied rental narrowed the options further.
Location rules. Carriers excluded homes by state (Kentucky, Florida), by ZIP code and by barrier-island location.
How each platform rates the zone. The same address was rated AE by FEMA and VE by one platform.
Policy form and fees. The same carrier (Hiscox, Vave) came in at different prices on different platforms, and only some platforms show fees and tax.

Even the NFIP isn't one price everywhere: on three homes, the NFIP companies on the same platform quoted different amounts for the same coverage.

Why a specialist matters

Having access to carriers isn't enough. You need someone who quotes all of them every time, knows each one's quirks (condo forms, elevation cutoffs, state limits, preliminary prices that must be re-created), and pushes back when a platform mis-rates your zone. Plenty of agencies name a long list of carriers. A list means nothing unless every carrier is actually quoted for every home.

Yep has supported more than 260 independent agencies across the United States over 15+ years in the flood business, on personal and commercial risks including condo associations, hotels, apartment complexes, wineries, homes and high net worth properties. We put the experience and the access to work for the customer, and we compare the all-in price and terms, not just the headline premium.

See what every carrier will charge for your home

Answer a few quick questions. We'll show instant quotes where available and email you the best results after quoting the rest.

Get your instant flood quote

Methodology and limits

Properties: 10 homes picked from public for-sale listings for variety in risk, property type and region (FL, TX, NJ, SC, CA, NC, KY, CO). Owner details are not used, and street addresses are withheld.
Platforms: Rocket MGA, Sterling, Flow and CRC (Argenia), quoted Oct 20–21, 2026.
Coverage basis: building $250,000, contents $0, $5,000 deductible, effective 11/19/2026. Some platforms enforce replacement-cost minimums, and Sterling showed higher-limit variants (not used for ranking).
Ranking: by base annual premium at a $5,000 deductible. NFIP indications at a $2,000 (or $1,250) deductible are shown but not ranked, because they can't be bound. CRC itemizes fees and tax and shows all-in totals; other platforms didn't show fees.
Risk data published: only FEMA zone, base flood elevation and the ground-to-BFE difference as rated by the quoting platform. FEMA zone and panel come from the National Flood Hazard Layer.
Assumptions: no elevation certificates were available. Foundation, enclosure and some building details were assumed and are labeled on each card. Real quotes will change once those details are verified.
Waiting periods: NFIP 30 days (with exceptions such as loan closings). CRC Hiscox and Vave showed 7 days (waivable). Others weren't shown.
Volatility: on one home (P10), re-pulling the saved quote later returned different numbers. Quotes are a snapshot in time.

FAQ

Why is one flood insurance quote not enough?

Because the cheapest carrier changes from home to home. Across the 10 homes on this page, 6 different carriers produced the lowest quote, and the gap between the highest and lowest quote for the same home ranged from 2.9× to 48.8×.

Does my flood zone determine my flood insurance price?

No, not by itself. Two Zone X homes here had lowest quotes of $125 and $435, and one Zone X home drew NFIP quotes of $4,600 or more. Carriers price with their own property-level risk models and underwriting rules.

Is private flood insurance always cheaper than the NFIP?

No. In this sample the NFIP was cheapest for 1 of 10 homes (Cape Coral, FL).

Why can't a page of average flood insurance prices tell me my price?

Averages and ranges blend very different homes together. For a single home in this sample the quotes varied by as much as 48.8×, and which carrier was cheapest changed from home to home, so a range can't tell you where your home lands or which carrier will win.

Are these quotes bindable?

They were live quotes and indications pulled October 20–21, 2026, at $250,000 building / $0 contents / $5,000 deductible, using stated assumptions (no elevation certificates). Prices change and must be re-quoted with verified details before binding.

How do I find the cheapest flood insurance for my home?

Have your exact home quoted across every available carrier and platform, with verified details like foundation and elevation, and compare all-in prices and coverage terms. That is what Yep does on every quote.